Horowitzs Cognitive Analytic Approach

Mardi Horowitz (1988, 1997, 1998, 2001) is widely recognized as a top name in PTSD research, theory, and practice. Although his treatment modality is somewhat of a hybrid in that he incorporates a fair amount of cognitive concepts into his work, the core of his work is typically considered psychodynamic. Horowitz himself refers to his treatment approach as cognitive-dynamic. He approaches PTSD as a disorder within a larger group of syndromes called stress response syndromes. He characterizes the pathology of stress response syndromes in the following way:

Stress response syndromes include emotional flooding with intrusive images and ideas. To avoid dreaded states of mind, people automatically inhibit information processing. That leads to denial, numbing, and avoidance. Because of avoidance behavior, attention to defensive coping and resistances to treatment is important. Hence, this cognitive-dynamic approach addresses patterns of defensive coping, efforts to counteract dysfunctional beliefs, and disturbances in roles of self and others. (2001, p. 181)

Traumatized individuals will predictably go through a series of alternating phases between acknowledging the trauma and avoiding it. As this process goes on, the eventual goal should be a reformulation or reschematization of the event in relation to the person and the person in relation to him- or herself and others. This is sometimes referred to as working through, which was mentioned earlier. The goal of treatment is to "help the person work through the linkage between the self and the stressor events so that all such symptoms can be attenuated or terminated" (Horowitz, 2001, p. 182). The goal is to strike a balance between a state of emotional numbness and of being emotionally flooded or overwhelmed. There are also the general goals of helping the patient establish a sense of safety; develop decision-making skills and more adaptive coping; develop a realistic sense of self as stable, coherent, competent, and worthwhile; develop competence with family and community; and develop a rational preparation and resilience for future stressors. Horowitz (2001) also proposes that steps should be taken to help patients protect themselves from danger by improving their attention and reaction times, and by teaching them not to react to erroneous beliefs, social stigma and shame, demoralization, or impaired physiological functioning due to sleep deprivation or altered neurochemical functioning. Horowitz's treatment, as are so many for PTSD, is complex and very thorough.

There are six phases to his treatment: evaluation/diagnosis/formulation/treatment planning, support, exploration of meanings, improving coping, working through, and terminating. Initially, patients are diagnosed with a particular stress response disorder, such as PTSD or Complicated Grief Disorder. Next, the clinician should formulate the goals and issues to be addressed within treatment. Horowitz (2001) offers the configurational analysis method for this process. First, symptoms and problems are selected. Next, the states or situations in which intrusive symptoms and states of numbing and denial occur are determined. In the next step, unresolved stress-related topics and defensive control processes are addressed. The fourth step addresses self-other beliefs related to identity and relationship functioning. The fifth and final step of formulation is an integration of the previous steps into a treatment plan.

The second phase of treatment is the support phase. Because patients may be in states of unmodulated affect and experience and may be feeling they've lost their sense of control, they need support. For Horowitz (2001), this may include biological stabilization with medication, social support with time structuring and enlisting supportive efforts, and the establishment of a supportive therapeutic relationship and concrete plan. Adequate support needs to be in place before the next phase of treatment, exploration, is undertaken. This is necessary because of the possibility of intense affect in this next phase.

In the exploration phase, intense and powerful affective experiences are analyzed in dose-by-dose fashion, with the goal of coming to conclusions regarding the event's meaning to the self. Horowitz states that blocks may occur at this phase and addresses them in the following way:

[the clinician] . . . may help the patient by clarifying the differences between realistic and fantasy-based beliefs. In doing so, the clinician allows the patient to learn by identification. The clinician is a person who is not overwhelmed by thinking about the implications of illness, injury, or loss. The presence of the clinician as a compassionate and empathic person, thinking logically, is reassuring. (2001, p. 192)

This is an important point when one considers the powerful experience the therapist may have in reaction to the discussion of traumatic material. (For more on issues of the impact of trauma work on therapists and countertransference issues, see Chapter 19.)

The next phase of treatment involves helping the patient improve his or her future coping style. These words are italicized because this treatment approach addresses the patients functioning in response to both current and anticipated stressors on the part of the patient-realistic or otherwise. It is explained that thoughts about the event or events are being inhibited and can be experienced in a dose-by-dose approach with "specific controls rather than global inhibitions" (Horowitz, 2001, p. 193) being utilized to cope. As defensive functioning is reduced, negative emotions will emerge but within the context of tolerable limits. If these experiences are too overwhelming, Horowitz (2001) suggests adding desen-sitization procedures for relaxation and self-control. Maladaptive defenses should give way to more consciously controlled and adaptive controls. Defensive operations such as inhibition of thought, suppression of emotion, distortion of reality, or dissociation need to be brought to the patient's attention and replaced. At this phase, Horowitz (2001) suggests the option of utilizing exposure techniques found in cognitive-behavioral therapy. (For more on cognitive-behavioral therapy, see Chapter 12.)

The working through phase is designed to help patients reschematize their identity and relationships. Patients analyze pretrauma personality beliefs about themselves and others. This may lead to specific themes being activated, such as fear of victimization, shame, feelings of incompetence, anger at the source of the trauma or a displacement figure, or guilt. An individual may also have a developmental history that leads to a lower threshold for tolerating despair and depression, which is then reactivated with trauma. Regardless of the various schematic and developmental material and issues that get activated, this phase of treatment involves helping the client differentiate between what comes from the past and what comes from the present. Attention to warded-off issues and trauma-specific struggles is intensified, and deeper interpretations are offered. These interpretations serve as a basis for a clearer sense of self and others within the context of the current trauma.

The final phase of treatment is termination. This is never a simple ending to therapy but a unique and important stage in and of itself. Emotions about separating from the therapist must be addressed. Also, therapeutic gains must be reinforced. Horowitz (2001) suggests making plans for practicing the newly acquired cognitive-analytic skills. He reminds us that the client's vulnerability is likely to resurface in this final phase and recommends terminating gradually over a series of sessions in an almost stress-inoculation manner. Finally, he recommends that the client be benevolently forewarned that these issues may crop up again but that this is expected and should be framed as a time to practice what has been learned.

Healing The Inner Child

Healing The Inner Child

Get All The Support And Guidance You Need To Be A Success At Changing Your Life. This Book Is One Of The Most Valuable Resources In The World When It Comes To What You Need To Know About Spiritual Emotional Freedom.

Get My Free Ebook

Post a comment